Free Consultation 24/7 
How a Missouri Case Changed Everything
According to legal experts, the 2023 Sitzer/Burnett verdict fundamentally changed how Americans buy and sell homes. The $1.8 billion jury decision found that the National Association of REALTORS (NAR) and major brokerages conspired to keep real estate commissions artificially high.
Now, two years later, NAR is still settling related lawsuits, including the recently announced $52.25 million Tuccori agreement, as the industry scrambles to adapt.
Attorney Michael Ketchmark, who represented Missouri home sellers Rhonda Sitzer and Scott Burnett, argued that NAR’s longtime “cooperative compensation rule” forced sellers to pay inflated fees to buyer agents.
Back in 2023, A federal jury agreed to hand down a massive verdict that sent shockwaves through the $100 billion real estate commission industry. NAR has since appealed the decision, but the practical effects are already here.
Why the Old System Was Ruled Illegal
Ketchmark successfully argued that NAR’s rules violated antitrust law by effectively price-fixing buyer agent commissions. Before the verdict, sellers had no way to opt out of offering commissions to buyer agents without removing their listings from the local Multiple Listing Service (MLS). That lock-in effect, the jury found, cost home sellers billions.
The distinction between the old system and the new one matters enormously. Previously, sellers bore the full cost of both their own agent and the buyer’s agent, typically 5–6% total.
Now, under NAR’s post-Sitzer settlement rules, buyer agents must sign written agreements with clients before showing homes, and commissions cannot be advertised on the MLS. This shift forces buyers to negotiate or pay their own agent’s fee directly.
NAR’s Ongoing Legal Fallout
NAR has ordered all its members to comply with these practice changes, which took effect in August 2024. The Tuccori settlement, announced April 10, 2026, reinforces those same rules without adding new requirements. It also grants broad legal protection to REALTOR® members, local associations, and MLSs against similar commission lawsuits.
Both Sitzer and Burnett have since become accidental industry icons, their names now shorthand for the legal reckoning that upended a century-old business model. Nykia Wright, CEO of NAR, has called the subsequent settlements part of the association’s “multi-year transformation” to deliver greater stability for members.
Real Estate Legal Representation in Las Vegas
If you’re facing legal issues related to real estate transactions, commission disputes, or antitrust questions in Nevada, it’s critical to work with an attorney who understands the post-Sitzer landscape. The right lawyer will explain how recent rule changes affect your rights as a buyer, seller, or agent.
Here at Partition Action, our team helps with real estate fraud, contract disputes, professional licensing issues, and other allegations involving bad faith or misrepresentation. Our firm has over eleven years of combined experience navigating complex litigation.
If you’re interested in learning how we can help with your real estate legal situation, schedule a free, no-obligation phone call with our office. Leave your contact details on our online form.
